It’s Time To Climb

My head is spinning. Yvon Chouinard’s memoir/manifesto, Let My People Go Surfing: The Education of a Reluctant Businessman, is the reason. I don’t know that I can successfully convey how important this book is. Yet, it’s imperative that I try.

prayer_flags.jpg

First, let me say this book is the best “ad” I’ve ever seen. I’ve been a hard core fan of Patagonia for 25 years, but this book/ad has deepened my respect for the company. The example being set in Ventura is encouraging to say the least. Knowing that business is being done differently–that is, with an ethical compass firmly in hand–is proof that there’s reason to be hopeful.

There are hundreds of pull-quotes to share, but check this one out:

When I die and go to hell, the devil is going to make me the marketing director for a cola company. I’ll be in charge of trying to sell a product that no one needs, is identical to its competition, and can’t be sold on it merits. I’d be competing head-on in the cola wars, on price, distribution, advertising, and promotion, which would indeed be hell for me. I’d much rather design and sell products so good and unique that they have no competition.

In other words, a product that needs very little, or better yet, no advertising.

5 Ways Online Marketers Waste Time

(4 votes, average: 4.5 out of 5)
 Loading …
Here’s a challenge for you: For the next week document what you do online and how much time you spend doing it. The outcome may surprise you. The fact is that many online marketers fritter away more time online than they spend working on their businesses.
It’s tempting. [...]

We Can Do Better Than Spam. Can’t We?

Scott Karp of Publishing 2.0 always has thought provoking content to share, which makes him one of the best bloggers I know of.

In a recent post, he states that “most online advertising creates NO value for consumers.” I’m not sure many other forms of advertising create value for consumers either, but I digress.

Consider this: What is the most successful type of advertising online advertising that convinces people to buy something they weren’t in the market to buy?

Email spam.

Spam is probably the most inefficient form of advertising every created, and it creates more hate and loathing among consumers than the worst 30 second TV ad ever created.

But it works. With millions of emails sent at virtually no cost, a 0.001% response rate can still be highly profitable.

Anchor trashes Rachael Ray, panic ensues

Not that I’d expect the strictest adherence to journalistic standards from Fox’s Good Day New York, but it’s still sad to watch an anchor backpedal after unknowingly ripping a sponsor’s ad. To be fair, the guy was actually ripping the…

An all out attack on knife crime

Warning! Video contains some bloody content!

(3 votes, average: 4.33 out of 5)
 Loading …
“As a knife enters the body, it tears apart the tissue structure.”
…begins a new advert (”it doesn’t have to happen”) in the attempt to reduce knife crimes in Britain, spoken by a doctor lecturing on how to treat victims of a [...]

Wrong Word

Do you crave intimacy with the brands in your life?

Please tell me the answer is “no.”

Writing in BusinessWeek, Sohrab Vossoughi, founder and President of ZIBA Design claims intimacy is desired.

Umpqua had to understand its own culture. What did Umpqua believe in? What was it good at? What did it stand for? What could it stand for?

After researching these questions thoroughly, Umpqua found its customers were craving intimacy. They were tired of the impersonal service they received from regular banks and suspicious of financial institutions in general. While other banks were competing with a convenience strategy centered around the Internet and ATMs, Umpqua identified an opportunity to provide customers with a “slow banking” experience that was both inspirational and encouraging.

Good customer service, yes. I’m all for it. But intimacy? Please.

Sex, Drugs and 1970’s Suburbia: Media Buyers Like ‘Swingtown’


NEW YORK (AdAge.com) — Media buyers like what they see in advance copies of CBS's new series "Swingtown," which debuts June 5. Set in 1970's suburbia with plenty of sex and drugs, the edgy drama is being compared to NBC's earlier period hit "American Dreams." Also in this 3 Minute Ad Age, a new report on the demographics of female blogging. And Kellogg's Hydrox cookies return to take on Nabisco's Oreo cookies after several years off the market.

Matt Dickman: Do You Own Your Digital Identity?

Do you own your corporate domain name? It sounds kind of silly in 2008 doesn’t it? Let’s go a level deeper. Do you own your personal .com name (i.e. www.mattdickman.com)?

That may be a bit more of a stretch for some of you, but it’s crucial from a personal branding perspective. Just ask Shel Israel who did not have www.shelisrael.com purchased and someone else put up a site devoted to poking fun at him.

Other heavyweights like Robert Scoble (www.robertscoble.com) don’t own their domain names either. Re-acquiring a domain name from a cybersquatter has some legal precedent, but it can rack of legal fees or large one-time purchase amounts.

iStock_000005643508XSmall.jpgHowever, let me ask you this. Do you own your personal/corporate Twitter username? How about your YouTube username? How about your Flickr username? If you don’t, it’s probably a good idea that you do (they’re mostly free anyway). I lost out personally on my YouTube name because I used my nickname instead. You may not acquire them all, but you can sure try. These usernames do come up with search result pages adding to the importance of owning your identity.

The risk to your reputation that you run when somebody does register your username is potentially huge. There is no legislation (which I am aware of) that addresses these micro level identity-squatters. It could get to a point where people/companies have to pay for their usernames ala the late 1990’s domain name deals.

Once you have acquired the usernames you will need to decide how, if at all, you use the account. While I don’t like the fact that accounts may sit empty in the short-term, it is advisable that you secure your ID as soon as possible.

What are you waiting for? Go claim your identity!

Paul Williams: How to Be Different: ‘Dominant Selling Idea’

In their book “Why Johnny Can’t Brand: Rediscovering the Lost Art of the Big Idea” Bill Schley and Carl Nichols Jr. share their idea of the dominant selling idea (DSI) and how to create a #1 brand. While you may be familiar with product differentiation these fellas talk about both product and brand differentiation.


Who:

Bill Schley and Carl Nichols Jr.

What:

“DSI” (dominant selling idea)

What is it?

It’s your “motivating difference” - the one difference that tips the scale in your direction versus all others at the moment of purchase. It’s what defines you as the #1 in a desired specialty… They say you have to satisfy these “Five Selling Ingredients” to make this happen…

Questions to Qualify Your DSIYou need to ask if your company or product…

  • Superlative - is best in class - better than the competition. Promise me something nobody else does.

  • Important - offers something that really matters. Something I really want or would be in the market for if I knew about it.
  • Believable - offers a logical reason, has credibility.
  • Memorable - has an emotional hook that sticks until purchase time. Do you have something not only that I need - but what I want. (This is the Free Prize)
  • Tangible - offers something real. Customers trust it because they’ve experienced it and it performed as promised. Must perform in a way that’s totally aligned and consistent with all of your claims.

How is is done?

There are several key steps that Bill and Carl suggest… I’ll outline them broadly below…

  1. Identify and choose your unique ownable specialty.

  2. Create a specialty statement… articulate your specialty.
  3. Create the five building blocks your DSI star.

1. Base + Extenders…

  • Identify your specialty by identifying or creating your ‘unique reason’ for being #1.

  • Add “extenders” to your “base specialty” until you separate yourself from the pack.
  • Base Specialty + (Extender + Extender + Extender) = Unique Ownable Specialty

Example:
Base Specialty = Lager Beer
Extender 1 = German (Lager Beer)
Extender 2 = Lite (German, Lager Beer)
Extender 3 = Non-Alchoholic (Lite, German, Lager Beer)

Non-Alchoholic, Lite, German, Lager Beer = Unique Ownable Specialty

2. Specialty Statement

Create for yourself a specialty statement which outlines what makes you #1.

“__________ (product/company) is the #1 choice for __________ (specialty). That’s because only __________ (product/company) has __________. (a unique reason why: a superlative ingredient, process, or service that other’s don’t).”

3. DSI Star

You need to complete all five of the star points to help us identify what our dominant selling idea (DSI) is.

  1. Your name. Is it meaningful? Does it convey what the company/product is about? Is it catchy and memorable?

  2. What is our unique ownable specialty - what do we do that no one else does?
  3. What tagline (or mantra*) encapsulates what you do? *More on mantra in the next post in this series about Guy Kawasaki. This is your “DSI wrapped in a magic word package.”
  4. What is our key image (worth 1000 words)? Not your logo… it’s an “indelible snapshot that demonstrates both performance and proof - you DSI - in a single flash.” This is your…
    Drinking Straw in the Tropicana Orange.

    Marlboro cowboy.

    Krazy Glue guy stuck to the girder.

    The fried egg (your brain on drugs) from the
    Partnership for a Drug Free America.


  5. Define our DSI-Level Performance - this is walking the talk. Creating total consistent alignment within our business. Our ‘service-level agreement’ with ourselves to maintain our DSI.

Of course, these highlights only scrape the surface of what is covered in the book. With my clients, I use this DSI work in combination with Seth’s “remarkability” and with “creating a Zag“.

Check Out

Books

Online


See also my previous DailyFix “How to Be Different” posts:

Yet Another Facebook Story: Get Thee To An Ikea

macys_couch.jpg

USA Today, like many others in the tech press, wonder what Zuck is going to do next.

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, asked at the D Conference if he would sell Facebook to Microsoft for $15 billion, said no. “The end goal for us isn’t to sell the company or an IPO. The way we evaluate (offers) is how are they going to help us along the way,” he said.

Maybe Google is one of those companies who can help. “We talk all the time,” Zuckerberg says. “The last time I talked to (Google co-founder) Larry (Page) and (CEO) Eric (Schmidt) at the same time they came over to my apartment.” But Zuckerberg said he’s not a fully-equipped host. “I have a mattress on the floor and this little table in the corner with two seats…Eric came and he had to sit on the floor.”

Only in Silicon Valley…

Dior Drops Sharon Like A Stone

The New York Times points to the downside of celebrity endorsement.

Christian Dior, the French fashion brand, has become the latest global company to learn a hard lesson about the danger of offending Chinese pride.

Facing the possibility of a boycott of its products, the luxury company said on Thursday that it had dropped the American actress Sharon Stone from its advertising in China after she suggested last week that the recent earthquakes in Sichuan Province were karmic retribution for Beijing’s treatment of Tibet.

Ms. Stone said last week during the Cannes Film Festival: “I’m not happy about the way the Chinese are treating the Tibetans because I don’t think anyone should be unkind to anyone else. And then the earthquake and all this stuff happened, and then I thought, is that karma?

If Stone knew what she was talking about, then I’d say we all better get under the table and brace ourselves, for very few humans are truly kind.

Texas gun-store owner clarifies ad slogan

Jim Pruett owns a gun shop in Harris County, Texas, and is worried that the Second Amendment could be overturned any second now, allowing jackbooted thugs to arrest anyone in possession of a firearm. While we’re not belittling his concerns…

Sponsor gives road trip an awkward twist

It takes a lot of guts to drive through all 48 contiguous states in the U.S. in less than five days. But for three guys to do the whole road trip with “Menlove” written on the side of their car?…

There are worse ad stars than Rachael Ray

Rachael Ray, a terrorist? It was an ugly scarf, certainly. But there’s a more sinister force at work in commercial land, one that threatens to poison the youth of this great nation with zippy harmonies and twangy guitars in the…

Where do I sign up for the sexy insurance?

I got an e-mail pitch today that began: “Have you noticed that the insurance industry, of all things, is becoming the surprising new hip marketer? … There’s even a social networking site called ‘Sexy Insurance!’ ” Too bad the pitch…

Make friends with a polar bear, if you dare

Here’s the first spot in Mullen’s “Power of action” campaign for utility company National Grid. My initial reaction is: Polar bears have broken out of the zoo! They’re stalking people in their homes and at work and at school and…

Graphic British ads aim to slash knife crime

Man, Europe is really going all out with the violent ad imagery these days. This time, England has come up with a campaign to scare kids away from knives that looks like it was taken from Jack the Ripper’s day…

Using That Gold Pencil As A Back Scratcher

Over at Ad Age’s The Big Tent Cat Lopez makes the surprisingly honest admission that he has to butter up other people in order to win awards.

I’ve been on a few awards juries, and they’ve all been great experiences, if not for the advertising itself as much as the lessons I’ve learned in human behavior. If an agency is on a hot streak and winning awards left and right, they usually get the benefit of the doubt for weaker submissions. They might get a bronze for something that should have stayed on the shortlist, or something that should have taken a bronze receives a silver. Because it comes from a hotshop, it must be good and must be awarded. Kudos to the agency for creating such a mystique; who doesn’t want to be in that position? Of course, that will eventually work against you. I’ve seen juries try to cool off a hot shop by making sure they don’t win the best of show for example. Not letting the competition get too much ink is also part of the lobbying process.

On the flip side are the not-so-creative agencies that never get any ink. Even a bad agency can do good work from time to time, but many of those agencies have a hard time getting their work onto the shortlist, the logic being they aren’t very creative, and therefore everything they do must suck. It happens. All the lobbying in the world won’t help these agencies until they begin to consistently deliver solid work. And even then, they still need to lobby.

Could you change this if you could prevent any award show judge from letting their own agency enter that show?

I think we’ll see a ban on lobbying for awards in the ad industry on the same day we see a ban on lobbying in Washington D.C.

In other words, never.

Sears Holdings Reports $56 Million Loss


NEW YORK (AdAge.com) — Sears Holdings, the parent company of Sears, Roebuck & Co. and Kmart, reported a $56 million loss for the quarter ended May 3. Analysts had been expecting the company to post an 89% decline in earnings to 15 cents per share. Instead, the company posted a loss of 43 cents per share.

Next generation advertising

Update! This is the video.
Most people today don’t have a very long attention span. If you’re like me, you won’t think twice about zapping forward to the next tv station if you don’t see anything good for two seconds.
Most advertisers are aware of this and are reaching for bigger and better adverts, spending millions [...]

Wherefore Art Thou, Hill | Holliday?

Hill | Holliday hasn’t updated their website since April 11th. I’m certain there are good reasons for it. Most likely the people who have been chosen to update the site are busy solving client problems (like finding Rachel Ray a new scarf). I get it. But, I also get that a blog as agency site isn’t the right answer if you can’t keep it up to date.

I don’t mean to pick on Hill | Holliday. They are far from the only agency with this problem. They’re just the most prominent.

If you ask Steve Rubel, he’d suggest putting some so-called “Millennials” on the job. If you ask me, I’d say it’s not about age, it’s about commitment to the form.

Ground Zero Adds Some Creative Muscle

According to Adweek, Ground Zero has added creative vet Curt Detweiler as partner and ecd. He started at the shop last week.

Aegncy creative partner and co-founder Court Crandall said Detweiler represents “the most important creative hire in the 14 years of our shop.”

Crandall said he has not had a creative partner at Detweiler’s level since the departure of creative partner Kirk Souder in 2001.

“Curt is among the select few that has the whole package to drive the business in a significant way,” Crandall said. “Great companies hire people better than themselves.”

Crandall said that Detweiler “thinks big like the good Chiat people always have.”

Don’t Pooh Pooh The Choo Choo

According to The Wall Street Journal, railroad companies are starting to market themselves as the ultimate eco-friendly, low-fuel-consuming industry.

For instance, a new CSX Corp. radio ad declares that even the most fuel-efficient hybrid car can’t compete with a train, which “can move a ton of freight 423 miles on a single gallon of fuel.”

“Too bad we can’t all drive a train,” the announcer says before urging listeners to visit CSX’s Web site to learn about the Jacksonville, Fla., company’s “commitment to protecting the environment.”

Freight trains now use much cleaner and more fuel-efficient diesel engines, and railroad companies are testing new engines that the industry is touting as “ultralow-emission.”

Many environmentalists acknowledge that the railroads have a powerful argument, given that freight trains burn far less fuel than trucks and can help reduce highway congestion.

Honda taking to the air for a live ad stunt

It’s hard to get people’s attention nowadays, so we should expect—nay, demand—bigger and better advertising stunts, preferably with a whiff of possible carnage. If David Blaine can get millions of eyeballs by holding his breath, why can’t a forlorn brand?…

Ad Guy Wants To Make Ecology Popular

If I read the press release correctly, Los Angeles agency 86theonions is now calling itself ecopop.

ecopop.jpg

In Chad Rea’s own words, “ecopop is about merging capitalism and global responsibility with a populist/iconic slant. Unlike the current trend, which involves corporate grandstanding and asking consumers to change, ecopop is committed to creating demand, influence, social currency, and profitability for businesses interested in social change. We do this by creating, marketing, advising or owning products and services, ranging from consumer goods to entertainment properties and media initiatives.”

In the wake of the recent green flood, Chad recognized it would be ridiculous to think that the majority of people in the U.S. really care about the green movement. In fact, it has become abundantly clear that the very word ‘green’ is enough to make most non-vegan Californians go out and buy a Hummer wrapped in non biodegradable fiberglass. The green community has succeeded in branding themselves as an elitist group, which is not in the best interest of our planet. Chad determined that green was just one color on the ecological spectrum, ecopop is the whole box of crayons.

Mack Collier: Worried About Bloggers Dissing Your Company? Read This.

Babblesoft founder Aruni Gunasegaram found herself in a position that any company would dread. She had launched a new product that she had hoped would be well-received by her target audience, mothers who breastfeed their children. Unfortunately, the product was immediately reviewed, and shredded, by Jennifer Laycock, a very popular mommy-blogger who blogs at The Lactivist. What happened next is a great lesson for companies wanting to handle crisis-management in the blogosphere.

Here’s what Jennifer said about the software program, Baby Insights:

I
don’t know about you, but the last time a family member had the gall to
ask me “what did you do all day” they got a talking to that made it
clear they were never, ever EVER to ask that question again. At least
not until our children were old enough to have children of their own.

Besides, when was the last time your friends and family members sat
down with you so that you could “proudly and confidently” show them
just how much time you spent feeding your baby in the last few days?

Am I the only one that wonders if this is a gag?

Understandably, Aruni was in a state of almost panic upon seeing
this. But what Aruni, and Jennifer did next, is a great lesson for
companies that want to interact with and respond to bloggers.

First, Aruni didn’t get defensive and lash out at Jennifer. That
would have made a potentially bad situation a four-alarm disaster.
Instead, she contacted Connie Reece at Every Dot Connects, who was
handling her PR, to seek Connie’s advice. Connie explains that

To
her credit, Aruni not only asked for advice, she followed it. She did
not respond in anger, but did her homework and learned something about
Jennifer, her blog, and her readers. When Aruni did add a comment to
The Lactivist, it was well received. She and Jennifer also exchanged
e-mails, establishing the basis for a relationship.

Aruni left a comment to Jennifer’s post
and graciously accepted the feedback from Jennifer and her readers, and
calmly stated her reasoning for creating the product. That was the
perfect response as it made Aruni look like she was confident in her
product.

But also notice how Jennifer reacted. In the comments section, while
some of her community agreed with her on the product’s potential
utility, some thought she was being too hard on the software, and added
that they could see themselves using it.

Jennifer eventually added in the comments:

While I
could still never imagine using a program like that myself, my readers
have really given some great reasons why it’s still a useful programs
for some moms….That’s the great thing about this blog. If I go on a
rant without thinking something through from all angles, my readers
aren’t afraid to call me on it.

Two big lessons here for companies:

1 - Even if a blogger slams you, how you respond is STILL more important. Aruni’s response determined the positive outcome.

2 - Bloggers are usually pretty reasonable people. Even though my good friend Jennifer
came out pretty hard on Baby Insights, she was reasonable enough to see
that some of her readers definitely disagreed with her opinions of the
software.

A bad product review from a popular blogger isn’t always the end of
the world. In fact if you keep your wits about you, it can actually be
the start of a friendship. As Connie adds:

Several
months later Aruni started her own blog, entrepreMusings, and she and
Jennifer follow each other on Twitter now. And to show what a small
world it is, I had dinner with Jennifer last month at BloggerSocial08
in New York. We shared a laugh over how the situation had unfolded and
how the former critic had become an ally.

BTW this episode is better explained in a great case study that Every Dot Connects just released.

Saving money on gas, ‘planet be damned’

The offer to cap gas prices at $2.99 for three years seems to be working for Chrysler, Jeep and Dodge. But it also appears to have started a contest among op-ed writers to see who can muster the most dire…

A few of Barack Obama’s favorite things

If Barack Obama wins the election this fall, some consumer brands can bask in the glory of being presidential favorites. A piece this week in The New York Times offered a list of Obama’s “likes and dislikes.” Though no brand…

With Rachael Ray, the terrorists always win

Leave it to the professionally offended to ruin everything. This time it’s Michelle Malkin, who led a charge of blogosphere criticism against Dunkin’ Donuts because one of its ads featured Rachael Ray wearing a scarf that sort of looks like…

Ad Agency Execs Jump In to Carry Olympic Torch


NEW YORK (AdAge.com) — JWT's CEO for China, Tom Doctoroff, has joined the 21 thousand individuals who will ultimately carry the Olympic torch to the opening of the games. The Shanghai-based ad executive also heads the agency that handles the account of Lenovo, one of the three sponsors of a China-wide online competition to win a place in the torch relay. Also in this 3 Minute Ad Age, Ben & Jerry's teams with the John Lennon estate on a new product. And, the surprising findings of a new study of fast food eaters.

Hydrox Cookies Back for a Limited Time


CHICAGO (AdAge.com) — Kellogg is resurrecting the 100-year-old Hydrox cookie in response to a consumer campaign that involved more than 1,300 phone calls, 1,000 petition signatures and "countless online message board postings." Hydrox cookies were pulled in 2003.

Kobe jumps

Following a tradition of “sure it’s a fake but wft” videos (i remember, right now, Ronaldinho’s and Lebron James’) presenting sports megastars now it’s the turn of (for me) the best basketball player over the court right now: Kobe Bryant….

Good First Impression

I’ve never heard of Toms Shoes until a couple of minutes ago. I’m sorry to say I’m not attracted to their footwear, but I love where they’re going with their give-away concept.

[via Fresh Creation]

How Nerdy Are you?

In Belgium, a weird website has recently appeared. How Nerdy Are You? is a project launched to state your level of “nerdiness” (my God what an awful word!). The site features a series of quick and amusing elements: a test,…

Lastminute.com theatre tickets

Guerrilla marketing should be both smart and surprising. I think Lastminute.com scored a good point with an unexpected musical performance at London Stansted Airport. A good idea to catch the attention of bored passengers in the waiting room and a…